Don’t let feds dictate gun rules

Print Article

There’s probably no better example of how a “one-size-fits-all” federal policy does not work than the opprobrious law that tells Montana schools what gun policies they shall adopt and enforce.

The issue got some well-deserved attention this week after a Columbia Falls High School student was regrettably suspended for having an unloaded hunting rifle in the trunk of her car while parked at school.

Demari DeReu, 16, was immediately suspended and faces an upcoming expulsion hearing based on district policy, which is itself based on a policy crafted by the Montana Schools Boards Association. That policy, in turn, was written to accommodate the 1994 federal Gun-Free Schools Act, which says states that receive federal education funding must require districts to have policies expelling for at least one calendar year any student who has brought a firearm to school.

Columbia Falls school officials have said they will not recommend expulsion in cases like DeReu’s and that the time she has spent suspended from school will count toward her punishment. So let’s not lay blame at the district’s feet. They seem to be taking a reasonable approach.

But why is the federal government dictating Montana school policies on guns in the first place? What may make sense in Chicago or Los Angeles doesn’t necessarily make it so in Montana, where guns and hunting are beyond common. We’d venture to say that only a couple decades ago, guns openly displayed on rear window rifle racks could be found in high school parking lots.

This is a state, after all, where Gov. Brian Schweitzer can show off a new handgun at an Inter Lake editorial board meeting, and no one bats an eye.

Sure, school officials can and should have policies that prohibit guns in the vicinity of a school, but they should also have the ability to apply discretion and common sense in enforcing those policies. In this case, the most notable element is the total absence of ill-intent and DeReu’s complete candor in trying to correct her mistake.

She went to school officials in an attempt to do the right thing, to make them aware of the rifle in her trunk and her desire not to violate any school policy. She got suspended instead, and now faces potential expulsion. Talk about the mixed message that sends to students!

Common sense should, and we hope will, prevail: DeReu’s time suspended should count as the expulsion, with no further punishment and no black mark on her record. This young woman should not suffer for an innocent infraction of a policy that should be determined entirely by local school officials who know her — with zip, zero, nada federal influence.

Want to weigh in on this issue? Visit www.dailyinterlake.com and vote in our online poll.

Print Article

Read More Editorial

Order on e-bikes conjures questions

September 08, 2019 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake A recent secretarial order from the Interior Department classifies electric-powered bicycles as non-motorized bikes. While seemingly insignificant at first glance, this order could alter the recreati...

Comments

Read More

Evergreen can overcome latest retail closure

September 05, 2019 at 9:52 am | Daily Inter Lake Kmart announced last week that it will be closing its Evergreen location after decades of serving the community. Liquidation sales will soon begin and by the end of the year the iconic “Big K” store ...

Comments

Read More

Citizens’ closure is a loss in planning arena

September 01, 2019 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake For 27 years Citizens for a Better Flathead has been the watchdog for land-use planning and smart growth in the Flathead Valley, but that oversight will now be gone as the nonprofit shutters its offi...

Comments

Read More

The bears are back in town

August 29, 2019 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake Kids are back in school, nights are getting chilly and bears are roaming town — three sure signs that the end of summer is near in Northwest Montana. Last week, Kalispell residents on Conrad Drive h...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 755-7000
727 East Idaho
Kalispell, MT 59901

©2019 Daily Inter Lake Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X