Paralegal wins legal ruling in ongoing dispute with state

Print Article

Flathead Valley paralegal and former state Sen. Jerry O誰eil has prevailed in a recent court ruling that denied attorney general charges that his advertising has been 電eceptive as a matter of law.

The Montana Attorney General痴 Office filed charges in June 2007 alleging that O誰eil violated the state痴 Unfair Trade and Consumer Protection Act, seeking summary judgment in the case.

But this week, Helena District Judge Jeffrey Sherlock denied that motion in a ruling with language that supports O誰eil痴 arguments.

滴e indicated my ads were not deceptive, O誰eil said Wednesday. 釘ut that was the only motion before him.

The case is not settled. Unless the state and O誰eil come to an agreement, the case will proceed to a jury trial.

O誰eil痴 legal tangles over his status as an 妬ndependent paralegal go back several years, resulting in Polson District Judge Kim Christopher affirming an injunction that prohibited him from practicing law or advertising that he is capable of doing so.

That resulted in O誰eil making some changes to his business cards and advertisements and in his business practices.

徹誰eil claims he has complied with the permanent injunction and is not violating MCPA, as he is not providing services that only a lawyer can perform and is now working under the auspices of an attorney, Sherlock痴 ruling states. 徹誰eil claims he only prepares forms for individuals seeking dissolutions or step-parent adoptions. Those forms are then reviewed by an attorney before they are filed with the respective court.

It is also noted that O誰eil pays his supervising attorneys.

Sherlock found that O誰eil痴 advertisements offering 鏑ow Cost Divorce do not warrant summary judgment and they 殿rguably comply with the 2005 injunction.

徹誰eil痴 new advertisements present a new set of facts, and the issue as to whether there has been any violation of the MCPA presents a jury question, Sherlock wrote.

The judge cited an affidavit in support of O誰eil from Kalispell attorney Dean Knapton: 適napton states that he has reviewed O誰eil痴 paperwork for step-parent adoptions and divorces and believes that even with an attorney痴 review of the paperwork prepared by O誰eil, clients are obtaining 鼠ow cost divorces as advertised by O誰eil.

Sherlock further noted that Montana Legal Services uses volunteers who are not lawyers to basically provide the same services that O誰eil does, and they do so without subsequent attorney reviews.

From O誰eil痴 standpoint, the state Attorney General痴 Office is seeking steep penalties against him: a $10,000 fine for each alleged violation; forfeiture of all fees received through alleged unauthorized practice of law; forfeiture of his business phone number and a permanent injunction banning from advertising or doing any legal work that only licensees lawyers can perform; and a $10,000 penalty for any future violations.

O誰eil said he is countersuing the state for 妬nterfering in my business, a pursuit he claims is motivated by resistance to any threat to the state痴 lawyer 杜onopoly.

Reporter Jim Mann may be reached at 758-4407 or by e-mail at jmann@dailyinterlake.com

Print Article

Read More Local News

Judge hears Egan Slough ballot initiative arguments

May 23, 2019 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake A river of Flathead Valley residents donning blue shirts in support of Yes! For Flathead Farms and Water flowed into the benches on the right side of the room at Flathead District Court on Tuesday mo...

Comments

Read More

Wife thanks doctors as trooper goes home after shooting

AP

May 22, 2019 at 3:42 pm | MISSOULA, Mont. (AP) A Montana Highway Patrol trooper who suffered a traumatic brain injury after being shot three times was released Wednesday from a Utah hospital after his wife gave emotional th...

Comments

Read More

Large-scale hazardous materials training underway

May 22, 2019 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake Members of the Kalispell Fire Department Hazardous Materials Team are conducting a joint training scenario today on the grounds of the Flathead Valley Community College with members of the Montana Na...

Comments

Read More

Edgerton student is national Scholastic essay winner

May 22, 2019 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake Edgerton Elementary School fourth-grader Violet Mellin was selected as the grand-prize winner in the Outdoor Alliance for Kids Scholastic Contest. Mellin痴 persuasive essay 滴ow Nature Improves the ...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 755-7000
727 East Idaho
Kalispell, MT 59901

©2019 Daily Inter Lake Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X