homes cars jobs apartments Merchandise Announcements

Archives > Opinion

Print | E-mail | Text Size

War, death and responsibility  

Published: Friday, March 28, 2008 12:24 AM CDT

Inter Lake editorial

Whatever their political persuasions, all Americans noted the unwelcome milestone this week of the 4,000th U.S. death in the war in Iraq.

It is hoped that the loss of our military service men and women in combat and hostile situations will never be taken for granted, nor used for political purposes. It should also be understood that the use of force will always involve casualties. We cannot expect to fight wars without suffering consequences.


On the other hand, it is always appropriate for Americans to decide whether or not they believe the use of force is appropriate, and whether the sacrifices we ask from our military are justified. That is an altogether separate question from honoring the bravery of our fallen heroes, who did not set policy but rather did the job they were asked to do.

In this presidential election year, it is important for the candidates to speak frankly about whether or not they believe those 4,000 heroic lives have been sacrificed in a good cause or not. Our country deserves to know what the future will look like under each candidate, and then to judge accordingly.

To some people, there is no cause worth sacrificing 4,000 lives. We disagree. The world can be made an infinitely better place because of the sacrifices of a few. But let us remember our responsibility as citizens to study carefully, to choose wisely, and to prepare adequately before we ask for the ultimate sacrifice from our best and brightest.

Residents of Flathead County can be proud of their health department’s continuing efforts to ensure that medical needs of our poorest citizens are being met.

On Wednesday, the Flathead Community Health Center received a $1.29 million grant from the state to increase staffing and buy new equipment. But as Gov. Schweitzer said, “This center started with compassion; the dollars came later.”

In fact, the center is open to everyone, but provides discounts to families who earn less than 200 percent of the federal poverty level. At Wednesday’s announcement ceremony, Schweitzer credited Rep. Bill Jones, R-Bigfork, and Sen. Dan Weinberg, D-Whitefish, for pushing the legislation that provided the grant.





 
 


Reader Comments

Views expressed in reader comments are solely the responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Hagadone Montana Publishing, LLC or its member newspapers. Users of the Web site can remove offensive comments by using the "Remove Comment" feature provided. (see rules) --- Webmaster


Don't see your comment? It could be your browser settings.

Posted by:Tillie 2008/03/29 05:10:10 AM
bush said the other day that he didn't want our soldiers to have died "in vain." to those of you who frequent this site, what does to have died in vain mean? if does it mean any time you lose a battle or a war or control of some territory those who participated died in vain? we lost in vietnam, did those soldiers die in vain?
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:ahzi 2008/03/29 09:59:27 AM
Frank hopes the 4,000 deaths "will not be used for political purposes." Unfortunately these men and women, and tens (hundreds?) of thousands of others have died for exactly that - the twisted political purposes of Bush/Cheney. I suggest Frank read "Daydream Believers" by Fred Kaplan - perhaps that will open his eyes to the idiocy of this administration.
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:cjrolphe 2008/03/29 08:36:12 AM
This war is all about money in the pockets of big corporations that are owned by the politicians. If you have not seen IRAQ FOR SALE you had better take a look(its on the web). Our men are dying for money and thats the bottom line This is the most disgusting use of our tax dollars there has ever been...and they want to cut social security? CUT THE DAMN INVASIONS OF OTHER COUNTRYS Get out and do it now. Stop feeding the dragons Americans. We are going down folks and that is inevitable at this rate But the politicians don't care as long as they are making their billions..check it out..its true
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:cjrolphe 2008/03/29 08:34:34 AM
This war is all about money in the pockets of big corporations that are owned by the politicians. If you have not seen IRAG FOR SALE you had better take a look(its on the web). Our men are dying for money and thats the bottom line This is the most disgusting use of our tax dollars there has ever been...and they want to cut social security? CUT THE DAMN INVASIONS OF OTHER COUNTRYS Get out and do it now. Stop feeding the dragons Americans. We are going down folks and that is inevitable at this rate But the politicians don't care as long as they are making their billions..check it out..its true
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:Rob 2008/03/29 01:55:48 AM
As a Veteran who voted for Bush, but wrote letters opposing the invasion in 2003, and find the whole experience of the past 5 years gut wrenching, I have one question: What do we do with Colin Powells "If you break it, you buy it" statement? To continue to continue to continue is absurd. Petraeus bought some time with deals and cash, but the roots of 'Clan Warfare' are so deep and ugly.....The present "Stay the Course" will happen until Bush leaves office, we all know that. But in Jan of 09, WHAT CAN WE DO? Just curious for feedback.
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:MontanaJim72 2008/03/28 06:03:42 AM
I guess when you live in "Bush-Cheney World", anything can be justified by saying whatever you need to say to achieve the desired result. No need to actually have proof, just say that you do. I read the other day that Cheney is saying that Iran is processing nuclear grade uranium, even though no credible source exists that says that is true. Just another example of "if we say it's so, then it is." This administration has zero credibility and if McCain doesn't distance himself from them, he can kiss the presidency goodbye. I only hope the country can survive the remaining months of "Bush-Cheney World"
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:mtboat 2008/03/28 11:26:48 AM
Five years in Iraq? Actually it's been 15. Lots of talk about ending the war in Iraq, talk of troop withdrawl from Obama and Clinton. This is a straw man,because they both would take it to Iran, when Iraq becomes passe.
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:j0 2008/03/28 09:47:14 AM
actually the number is around 70,000 dead. they airlift the wounded out of the iraq theatre and then if they die it doesn't count as a war casualty. 4,000.. 70,000... all for.. cheap oil? we didnt get that.. exactly what are we winning for the blood spilt...
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:Kalispell Native 2008/03/28 08:32:43 AM
Hey Frank, is this war worth another 4,000 lives? What have we accomplished over there? How did you calculate that the lives of the first 4,000 were "worth it"? Support our troops. Bring them home. There aren't any "weapons of mass destruction" to be found over there. Bush was plain wrong. Now it's time to come home.
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Posted by:bimmermt 2008/03/28 08:11:24 AM
Look closely at this war folks. We have recycled troops, some for the third time, to a war zone. The long-term effects of that intensity will be our responsibility. This war was not necessary and has done nothing but destabilize a less than stable country. The only time there is a quell in fighting is when the Sunni culture decides to allow for it. We seem to have little influence regardless of the rhetoric from the commanders on the ground. So, sad to say, another war, military casualties, nothing gained, all in vein. Who are we?
Block this blogger Remove this comment

Express yourself. Register once and comment on any story. Start Here!

User Name: password:
Email:
Comment:
Lost Password? --  Change Password / Name?

Return to: Opinion « | Home « | Top of Page
 
Today's Weather
Kalispell, MT