Local-option tax long overdue

Print Article

Just as there is a divide between big cities and small towns in national politics, so too there is a marked division between urban areas and rural counties in Montana ó and never is that division more marked than when the topic is local-option sales taxes.

Every two years, cities from across Montana send representatives to Helena to lobby the Legislature for the ability of city residents to impose a sales tax that would supplement property taxes as a means of paying for infrastructure and other needs.

And every two years, just as predictably, representatives and senators from small towns and sparely populated counties push back against the idea. Thatís because rural Montana residents often recreate in those bigger towns and cities, so they would be paying the tax while not getting back any of the revenue.

This week, the debate was renewed. Rep. Dave Fern, D-Whitefish, is the sponsor of House Bill 577, which would allow local governments to impose a sales tax of up to 4 percent on lodging, restaurants, bars and luxury items. Fernís involvement is welcome. As a resident of Whitefish, he is well aware of the success of the resort tax (a limited form of sales tax) in that community, so he makes a good ambassador for the concept.

Kalispellís city manager, Doug Russell, testified on Tuesday before the House Taxation Committee that the city could raise an estimated $6.5 million per year from a 2 percent tax. Thatís actually more than the city collected in property taxes last year. What a windfall for strapped municipalities.

The goal of sales-tax proponents is to see out-of-state visitors pay for part of the infrastructure they use in cities like Kalispell and Bozeman, and that makes sense. Moreover, local property taxes would be partly rebated back in cities with a local-option tax, so this is a form of tax relief as well.

The best argument against the sales tax is that it wonít apply to online sellers like Amazon, so there is an incentive for local shoppers to take their money elsewhere to avoid the tax. But letís face it, that only applies to the luxury items ó not to hotels, restaurants and bars. People arenít going to be ordering their meals and drinks online, and the folks who are paying for luxury items probably have enough spare change that they arenít going to be hindered by a 4 percent surcharge.

Itís a long shot that the Legislature will approve the bill, and even less likely that Gov. Steve Bullock would sign it after he won re-election partly by painting Greg Gianforte falsely as a sales-tax proponent.

Still, itís a good idea whose time surely must come sooner or later. If it doesnít work out this session, weíll be back two years from now making the same arguments.

Print Article

Read More Editorial

Drug court makes sense for Flathead

October 15, 2017 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake As Flathead Valley law-enforcement agencies battle an increase in the use of meth, heroin and prescription medicines, itís encouraging to hear judicial officials and law-enforcement leaders talking s...

Comments

Read More

Bump-stock ban isnít gun control

October 13, 2017 at 1:24 pm | Daily Inter Lake Most of us, like most of you, had never heard of a bump stock until a few weeks ago when the Las Vegas massacre proved their deadly punch. But once becoming aware of them, it was a quick and easy d...

Comments

Read More

EDITORIAL: Donít make hasty decision on county jail site

October 08, 2017 at 5:00 am | Daily Inter Lake Itís more or less a foregone conclusion that Flathead County likely will have to find a site to build a new adult detention center thatís big enough to hold the countyís prison population well into t...

Comments

Read More

EDITORIAL: Local folks do us all proud in Vegas

October 06, 2017 at 11:13 am | Daily Inter Lake The tragedy in Las Vegas came close to home for several Flathead County residents who happened to be in attendance at the Route 91 Harvest music festival Sunday when a depraved killer opened fire on ...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 755-7000
727 East Idaho
Kalispell, MT 59901

©2017 Daily Inter Lake Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X