Man appeals sentence for killing three grizzlies

Print Article

In March the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals will consider the appeal of a man convicted of killing three grizzly bears that had been killing his chickens in the Ferndale area in May 2014.

Oral arguments in the case of Dan Calvert Wallen, 56, are set to be heard at the federal Pioneer Courthouse in Portland, Oregon on March 8 at 9 a.m.

Wallen was found guilty in a bench trial by a single judge in May 2015 of killing three grizzly bears a year earlier in the Ferndale area with a .22 rifle. The bears had been getting into his chicken coop.

His defense counsel argues that the case should have been heard by a jury and that Wallen’s claims of self-defense should have been considered.

Under federal law, lone judges can consider misdemeanor cases in federal court in which a defendant faces “petty” consequences, which are defined as a maximum sentence of six months of incarceration and a fine of up to $5,000. Wallen’s attorney argues that he should have been granted a trial by a jury of his peers because his sentence – $15,000 in restitution and three years probation – was beyond the measure of “petty” consequences.

“Here, the custodial/fines/restitution/supervision penalties are so severe that Wallen deserves a jury trial,” wrote John Rhodes, of the Federal Defenders of Montana, in the appeal. “The maximum fine is $25,000 per count. And the government values restitution at $10,000 per bear.”

Rhodes also argues that Wallen had a good case for self-defense. Federal law requires that violators of the Endangered Species Act be found to not have “a good faith belief” that he or she is acting to protect himself, herself or others from bodily harm.

According to the appeal in an affidavit Wallen wrote that, “I was fearful for myself and my family.”

“The district court ignored it,” Rhodes wrote of the affidavit. “And the investigating agent never questioned Wallen about fear, even after he wrote out the affidavit.”

Rhodes argued that even if the court doubted Wallen’s testimony, others who spoke at trial established the bears, which Wallen claimed were 20-30 feet away when he fired the final shots, were a threat.

“Numerous neighbors testified of being scared of the bears,” Rhodes wrote. “Witnesses or defendants can lack credibility and still have a subjective good faith fear of wild animals, particularly three grizzly bears that return to their property four times in less than 24 hours, including three times when themselves and/or family members are outside of their home, where the bears speedily approached them.”

The prosecution has countered Rhodes’ arguments in briefs and supported the judge’s guilty verdict.

“This determination was based on factual findings that Wallen’s testimony that he acted in self-defense was not credible,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Megan L. Dishong wrote. “The trial court noted that ‘Wallen has given three accounts of the events’ surrounding the shooting of the bears.”

The federal government also argues that it is well established through case law that a single count of an Endangered Species Act violation does not warrant a jury trial and that Wallen should not have been given a trial simply because the cumulative potential punishment for the three charges he was convicted of are in excess of what is typically considered “petty.”

Wallen asks for a jury trial as remedy in the case.

Reporter Megan Strickland can be reached at 758-4459 or mstrickland@dailyinterlake.com.

Print Article

Read More

Assault suspect apprehended after 5-hour manhunt

May 23, 2017 at 10:47 am | Daily Inter Lake A five-hour manhunt involving three different agencies ended with the suspect, a Columbia Falls man, being handed over by his father at the Columbia Falls Police station early Tuesday morning. Aft...

Comments

Read More

Wind advisory issued for Flathead Lake

May 23, 2017 at 2:02 pm | Daily Inter Lake Exceptionally windy weather is expected across much of Western Montana on Wednesday with gusts up to 40 mph in the Flathead Valley likely. A wind advisory was issued for the Flathead and Mission v...

Comments

Read More

Body of missing Kalispell woman found in river

May 23, 2017 at 11:10 am | Daily Inter Lake Authorities on Sunday recovered the body of a missing Kalispell woman from the Flathead River. A fisherman reported finding the body 2 miles upstream from the Sportsman Bridge south of Kalispell on...

Comments

Read More

Committee focuses in on school expansion plans

May 23, 2017 at 6:00 am | Daily Inter Lake Plans are coming along for the design development phase of the renovation and expansion of Flathead High School. A committee made up of district administrators, high school staff, school board trust...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 755-7000
727 East Idaho
Kalispell, MT 59901

©2017 Daily Inter Lake Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X